Don’t let the title fool you, Castle of Fear is rum and raisin and it’s heavy on the rum. If some strange intergalactic anomaly ever caused Doctor who and Monty python to be crossed this would be the outcome. Heck the Holy Grail even gets a name check; as does the Python staples of Knights with OUTRAGOUS French accents. Scenes have not so much been stolen as given homage and while it may cause you to check the box cover to ensure its Doctor Who it’s a lot of fun. I got a lot of strange looks for laughing loudly in a crowded train when I heard the rather cheesy Blacksmith joke but I dare you all not to laugh when you hear it; you’ll know which one.
It took me a while to realise that Casle of Fear was this flavour. It takes until episode 2 before you can be sure as it does tend to veer a bit in tone. The opening is brilliant and catches you off guard; the ending is truly shocking. And there are some nice who staples; multiple time zones playing off each other in what I think is a unique and interesting way ( I’ll probably be corrected about this)
The Baddie is a named who villain. I’m not going to spoil it but it’s not a major league player but it was a nice return. The only minor grip is that its voice makes you think of another villain. Not the production teams fault. It has a very distinct on screen look which helps the voice seem different on TV and the audio doesn’t have this advantage. The threat is also nicely integrated into established who lore.
What is it about then? Well it’s hard to give to much away but it’s a historical. We’re drawn into the story of Hubert, The new Earl of Mummerset, trying to regain his Castle. With his Turkish aid he may at first seem a bit Robin Hood but that doesn’t last for long; Hood only had to deal with an evil sheriff. Hugo finds he needs to evict a bunch of Demons from his Castle. While this is going on the Doctor and Nyssa are hundreds of years away, enjoying a traditional Stockbridge Christmas play. But when the Dragon slays St George it’s only a matter of time before they have to cross Hugo’s path…
The music does a good job of setting the scene and the sound work is excellent. The actors certainly enjoy themselves and while some of the support performances are a bit OTT it works rather well. It’s also a nice touch that we have the same actors playing their characters descendants over time zones. This works really well as the story comes to a close. Davidson and Sutton work really well together. Nyssa works much better as a companion when she’s one on one with the Doctor and its nice to see both of them giving top notch performances; even as the tone of the story jumps around. When the danger is there the sense of fear and urgency is conveyed very well but both of them are happy to go with the flow when things turn comical. Nyssa also shows she’s not just a Damsel in distress and is very proactive in the resolution.
This is the most fun I’ve had listening to an audio in a long time. While I normally enjoy them I had a constant smile listening to this tale. It may not be for everyone; its Monty Python trappings could annoy people wanting a more serious tale. But this story has a lot going for it and while it’s light in tone the ending certainly isn’t and should catch you off guard.
A recommended 8/10